← Back to Writing

Community Strategy & Measurement

Size Doesn't Matter

Membership counts don't reveal whether people participate, return, or find value in a community.

👉🏻 SIZE DOESN’T MATTER 👈🏻

Have I got your attention? Good.

When it comes to communities, size really doesn’t matter. Participation does. Here’s a real-life example.

I met with a newer community manager to talk shop. The community they managed was established and gaining about 10 new members per month.

When the conversation turned to measures of community health, they leaned on size. “We have more than 2k members,” they said.

“That’s amazing,” I said. “Of those 2k members, how many participate in a typical month?”

That gave them pause. Finally: “10, maybe 20.” That’s 0.5–1% monthly participation.

Nearly all of them were the same members. Occasionally, a new voice would appear, contribute a post or two, then go quiet.

An established community with 2k members, a handful group of regular contributors, and occasional posters who don’t stick around?

It’s barely registering a pulse.

Depending on your definition of community, it could be argued that theirs might not yet be one. But that’s another post for another time.

I encouraged them to consider engagement as a measure of community health, and to get curious about why members aren’t participating and/or returning.

Ask new and existing members about the “why.” Audit onboarding and contribution processes for friction. Then, test and fix what’s not working iteratively until it does.

Bigger isn’t better. Engaged is.

Does this sound like your community or one you’ve managed in the past?

Let me know in the comments.

And if you need help auditing and/or turning around your community, DM me.

Building something new, scaling what works, or rethinking what could work better?

Let's talk about the customers you're serving and the outcomes you're working toward.

Let’s Talk